Justice for Mantigue Island, Camiguin residents

My family and I went to the Island of Camiguin a few months ago. What supposedly was a time to relax and unwind turned out to be work somehow. You see, when we visited the beautiful islet of Mantigue in Camiguin (the “less popular” islet — tourists usually go to the famous White Island), we learned from the residents there that the local government has started to send them feelers. The residents said that the local government wanted them off the island as soon as possible because they were considered “illegal occupants.”

The residents opined, however, that most of them have been born in the island. They asserted that they were “natives” there and that they grew up knowing only one home and that is Mantigue. Over the years, they learned how to fish, culture seaweeds and eventually welcome and cater to tourists who wanted to spend the day on the island. They said that they have somehow built a community and they even have a small elementary school and Catholic chapel within the island. I found their story a bit interesting.

Fast forward a few months later, the Supreme Court released a statement saying that the Island of Boracay is public property. That reminded me of the 4.4 kilometer-wide Mantigue Island issue. Apparently, if the circumstances concerning both islands are a bit similar, then I wouldn’t be surprised if the Camiguin government would also state that Mantigue is also public property. I’m sure that the Camiguin local government unit can’t wait to get its hands on the island and develop it as a major tourist spot because really, as you can see in the photos I took, the island is spectacular. From what I’ve gathered so far, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) has issued Administrative Order 98-13, reverting Mantigue Island’s category to forest land. As such, anybody who’s staying there would indeed be considered as illegal occupants.

Unfortunately, I learned from the residents themselves (based on the numerous text messages that they sent me) that roughly 42 families have already been charged with illegal occupancy and that some of their companions have been imprisoned while some have pending warrants of arrest.

The Camiguin LGU reportedly offered a relocation site in Barangay San Roque but like most relocation sites, there’s hardly any available source of livelihood there. The government also reportedly pledged to give each family a sack of rice plus P5,000.00 and a so-called 10-day carpenter assistance. Moreover, the local government pledged to give P10,000.00 to each family that will opt to transfer outside the relocation site plus livelihood assistance.

And well, like most government-led pledges, those weren’t followed, according to the residents. They told me that the families that decided to leave the island only got a half sack of rice each and got carpenter assistance for only 5 days. Some residents also said that the families that opted to stay in the island are now shivering in fear since the government still continues to demolish their shanties. Some of them even receive threats.

It’s really alarming whenever we hear situations like these. First you drive people away from their homes then you have the gall to offer some sort of severance but then you don’t keep your end of the bargain. And you expect people NOT to go back to their homes and just continue on with their lives or complain and fight for their rights? Exactly where’s the justice in that?

While I understand that there’s need for us to boost tourism and all that – there are still a lot of other options, truth be told. Offer these families livelihood programs. Solid, working, feasible ones, please. And make sure that all these efforts will really be good for everyone in the long run. I’d hate to learn that only a few will benefit out of this so-called “eco-tourism” project. I’d hate to know that a large hotel chain will be given preference over tens of families. I’d hate to learn that some big-time businessman who happens to be a friend of “someone in power” will basically be laughing all the way to the bank while families are left homeless, hungry and helpless.

Like this post? Let's stay connected :) Please subscribe by email HERE or let's talk here: Twitter Instagram Facebook Google Plus Snapchat

Mindanaoan Irene

Mindanaoan is a multi-awarded blogger, social media strategist, publicist, Google Business Group - Women lead organizer, avid traveler and a proud relief operations volunteer. She is also a regular resource person for social media and blogging related conferences/workshops here and abroad. In 2012, Mindanaoan also completed a US Gov't. Department of State-sponsored International Visitor Leadership Program for emerging global leaders. She toured the U.S. for about a month for her IVLP experience. She is the founder of a bloggers group and social media club. She is also an active member of several online media, bloggers and social media enthusiasts groups all over the world. Mindanaoan is available for work and travel. Contact Mindanaoan at mindanaoan@gmail.com

7 Responses

  1. Nicely says:

    Hi, Mindanaoan! I would like to ask permission to use one of your photos in this post for a blog post.

    I put it here: http://travelingnicely.com/2011/08/why-i-want-to-experience-and-join-camiguins-lanzones-festival/

    Please let me know if it’s okay with you—I hope.

    • Hi there! Oo naman, no problem 🙂 Thanks so much for visiting my humble blog. Enjoy your stay in Camiguin! If you need any help at all, please feel free to ask 🙂

  2. Nicely says:

    Ooops! I thought I already said thank you. Hehe.

    Salamat po and pasensya na sa abala 🙂

  3. Jannah Sapa says:

    Hi Mindaoan. I would like to ask if we could get some details here for our thesis regarding about this issue. Thank you. 🙂

  1. October 1, 2009

    […] to bring your camera, lots of suntan lotion (Mindanaoan highly recommends that you visit both Mantigue Island and White Island), swimwear and other travel essentials…just don’t bring sand, please! […]

  2. July 12, 2013

    […] I say “feeling” because in truth, several families do live in the island but since that controversy between the settlers and the local government started, they’ve now been relocated to the other side of Mantigue […]

  3. November 11, 2016

    […] Magsaysay Island ist ein Paradies für Schnorchelfans. Die Insel ist noch ein absoluter Geheimtipp und kann gut innerhalb eines Tagesausflugs von Camiguin aus besucht werden. Nach 20 Minuten Bootsfahrt ist man bereits angekommen und kann sich in Ruhe den etlichen Korallenriffs widmen oder die Aussicht auf Camiguin genießen. Neben den tausenden Fischen, die sich entlang des flachen Wassers herumtreiben, leben auf der Insel selbst ca. 200 Fischer und Fischerinnen in einem kleinen Dörfchen. Sie gehören zu den freundlichsten und offensten Menschen, die ich jemals erlebt habe. Leider haben sie schon seit Jahren mit Androhungen der Zwangsumsiedlung zu kämpfen. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copy Protected by Tech Tips's CopyProtect Wordpress Blogs.